Noble Nexus
All insights

Practical guide

Permanent hire or independent consultant: how to decide

The decision depends on how long the work will last, who needs to own it, and what should remain in the team afterward. Timing and cost also matter.

Salim Kamoun

Founder, Noble Nexus

3 min read

When a team needs more capacity or new expertise, the first instinct is often to open a position. Before doing so, it is worth asking what that person will do once the immediate work is finished.

We support clients with both: independent consultants for projects, and permanent recruitment for full-time roles. Because of that, we often have this conversation at the very start. These are the questions we find most useful.

What will remain after the current work?

If the need comes from a specific project, ask what work and what responsibilities will remain when it ends. If there is a clear and lasting role, a permanent hire makes sense. If the answer is uncertain, it may be better to start with a defined engagement and decide later.

Who needs to own the result?

A permanent role usually makes sense when the organization needs someone to take lasting responsibility: for a function, a team, or a set of relationships. An independent consultant can lead a piece of work, but the decisions that follow from it will stay with the organization. If nobody inside is in a position to own those decisions, that is the role to fill first.

How much of this expertise will you need?

Some expertise is needed in depth, but for one assignment: a specific regulation, a system migration, the first entry into a new market. Before creating a role, consider whether there will be enough relevant work to justify it afterward. A shorter engagement may make it possible to bring in someone whose experience you need, but whose full-time cost would be hard to justify.

When does the work need to start?

A permanent hire takes time. There is the search, the interviews, the offer, and then the notice period of the person you have chosen. If the work must start before a permanent hire can join, an independent consultant may be able to cover the gap while the search continues. Timing should guide the immediate decision. It should not decide the long-term shape of the team.

What is the real cost of each option?

A day rate and a salary are not directly comparable. A permanent hire brings recruitment costs, benefits, and a commitment that continues after the project. An independent consultant costs more per day, and also requires time from the team: to brief them, to supervise the work, and to organize the handover. The comparison is only meaningful over the full length of the need.

How the two work together

In practice, the two options often support each other.

An independent consultant can lead a function for a few months while the permanent search takes place, so that the organization does not have to hire in a hurry. An experienced consultant can set up a new team and help define the role of the person who will lead it. And when a need is still unclear, a first engagement can help the organization understand what it requires, provided that this is part of the brief from the start.

Agreeing what the role is for, before starting any search, makes it much easier to choose the right kind of support.

Salim Kamoun

Founder, Noble Nexus

Need an independent consultant?

More insights